Tonight was the night I would put an innocent man to death.
“Death by ash, or by ice?” Magnate Elías Adriann asked as he stood over the convict on a granite stage. It was impossible to find a resemblance between Elías and the kneeling prisoner; without knowledge of the scandal, no one would have guessed they were cousins.
Brian Adriann, now tasked with deciding how he wanted to die, only shivered in response. Ice crusted his beard and hypothermia had left his extremities black and gnarled like overcooked meat. A starry sky illuminated pockets of prison cells at the top of the chasm, where Brian had roomed for the past week. Augustins called it The Lid. Weeks of malnutrition up there, so close to the sink hole’s lip, had already turned him into half a memory.
“Death by ash, or death by ice?” Magnate Elías repeated. He twisted the ring on his forefinger, expression grim, as if taking no pleasure in the trial. I knew the truth.
Brian whimpered, and the sound summoned vivid images of how I would kill him. Would he care if I had no choice in the matter? Of course not. Mole rats didn’t care who held the knife during their slaughter. But what about the people crowding the street, intently watching the trial? Would they be capable of sympathy?
Shame left an acidic taste on my tongue. I didn’t want my part in this trial to affect how they saw me, even when an innocent man was about to die.
Love the opening line. There are only a few lines/words that stuck out in a possibly negative way to me, and of course this might be nitpicking but with only one page to go on, that's kind of the nature of this. The guards "behind the two participating in the trial" seemed a bit distracting and unnecessary. Could they just be standing nearby? You mention that Elias and Brian are cousins. I assume this will play a role in the story later on? Because if it is just to show the cruelty or unfeeling nature of the Magnate, it might be a bit unnecessary. Same for the line "as if taking no pleasure in it" - his expression shows this sufficiently for us to assume he takes no pleasure, I think, so adding on the 'as if' makes me question it: DOES he take no pleasure in it? If this is not your intent, I would remove that portion of the sentence and let his expression do the work. Otherwise I liked it, I am definitely interested to see the outcome of the trial and would keep reading if I picked it up at the bookstore. Good luck.
This first page really has a great deal of tension, and that's great. I got confused in some of the elements because you introduced many of them by name rather than by what those things were. It doesn't take a ton of "stage directing" to paint a picture of what's going on, but that's my personal preference. I like to know that there are people in a room before they talk, etc. (unless those words are meant to be surprising). I do think the previous comment has some excellent points. I did have one nitpick that really drew me out of the story: I'm confused about the spears glittering with lava from beyond the shallow ridge. Is this a reference to a portal, or are they dipping their spears in lava? In which case, glitter doesn't seem like the right word. Lava doesn't typically glitter. It's most commonly sullen and red, and the consistency of honey (if it's red enough to glow), which makes it a terrible thing to dip spears into. I don't wonder if you are trying to give us too much of your world in one go round. It might serve you better to let this page breathe a little and give us some of these details so your reader feels more grounded. And just to be clear, it's really good as is, these are just my thoughts for improvement. Good luck!
Tonight was the night I would put an innocent man to death. (Great first line).
“Death by ash, or by ice?” Elías Adriann asked, standing over the convict cowering prisoner on a the granite stage. It was impossible to find a resemblance between Elías Adriannand the cowering prisoner;(do we need full name twice? actually, do we need this lien at all) Without knowledge of the scandal, no one would have guessed they were cousins. (Maybe a line here to give us a sense of the magnate's power and influence, perhaps a menacing sentence to let us know that no-one will ever know of the scandal because the magnate's gonna make damn sure anyone with knowledge gets the ash or ice?) Brian Adriann—the magnate’s own blood (complicated way of telling us Elias is the magnate?) tasked with deciding the means of his execution—only shivered in response. (maybe give us a bit more - the look on his face, his telling silence, the hate in his eyes - just shivering might imply he's only cold, especially with the sentence that follows) Flakes of ice crusted his beard, and hypothermia had left his extremities black and gnarled like overcooked meat (see what you're shooting for here but not sure this analogy works because we've got this image of freezing cold and then suddenly it's overcooked meat. if you nix the metaphor altogether it's probably stronger). A starry sky illuminated pockets of prison cells at the top of the chasm, where Brian (after such a powerful beginning, the name Brian seems to stick out to me. Also, this smells a little of purple prose and who's the narrator? We start with "I was about to put an innocent man to death" and suddenly we seem to be looking at the starry sky and worrying about Brian?) had roomed (roomed doesn't seem sinister enough - had been incarcerated?) for the past week. Augustins called it The Lid. (another name - who's Augustins, why should we care what he thinks?) Weeks of malnutrition up there, so close to the sink hole’s lip, had turned him into a memory of his old self. (I don't understand this line - ie who it refers to - it can't be Brian because he'd roomed there for only a week, and a memory of his former self is a cliche)
“Death by ash, or death by ice?” Magnate Elías repeated. He twisted the ring on his forefinger, expression grim, as if taking no pleasure in the trial. (Maybe just refer to Elias Adriann as Magnate Elias from the get go - then you could use Adriann instead of Brian which sounds stronger. We know they're cousins, so it probably doesn't matter if we're not told they share the same surname)
Brian whimpered. Every sound that escaped his throat summoned vivid images of how I would kill him (how? what does this actually mean?). (okay so we're now back in the executioner's head - which is good - but I think there needs to be some connection/communication/body language between Magnate Elias and the executioner so we understand better what's going on. We don't even know where the executioner is in relation to everyone else - is he on the same stage, is he looking up at the sky, is he in the crowd (is there a crowd) - I think we need to ground the reader better in how these people are positioned, particularly the MC) Would he care if I had no choice in the matter? Of course not. Mole rats didn’t care who held the knife during their slaughter. But what about the people crowding the street, intently watching the trial? Would they be capable of sympathy? (Ah, so there is a crowd - and yet we've no sense of that, we've no sense so many eyes are watching until now. Need to see more of this I think, show us what's happening more vividly).
Comments inline Charmon, but I loved the query and the first page setting is terrific. I think because it's got the potential to be such a powerful opening I've been really picky - please forgive me for being so - but I don't feel as though we're truly in the MC's POV as closely as we should be for much of this opening and if you can give us a better sense of what he's feeling, his distaste for the MAgnate's actions, his empathy for Brian, even a hint of the nature of the scandal and the baying of the crowd, it would make all the difference. As ever though, your story not mine so take every comment with a pinch of salt, just my own personal take and we now how subjective this business is! Good luck either way, I thought your query was terrific and I'm intrigued to learn more about our executioner's journey. Great concept.
Hey You read my first 250 words and I wanted to return the favor. I sincerely hope my comments are helpful. Just remember, our comments are suggestions only - always listen to your heart when deciding if a piece needs revisions. I mean, all our thoughts are based on our own reading style/preferences, so what each critiquer may think could vary wildly from the rest of the world. Overall Comments/Good Questions the work left me with: I get an impression of the setting you’re hoping for. What I suggest is to flush out this new description of world & stage you’re presenting to the reader, and give a Deep POV from your main character to show the reader how this scenario is affecting him emotionally and the physical responses he has as a reaction to his emotions.
I may paste excerpts from your work below and will comment using [CDH - ]
Tonight was the night I would put an innocent man to death. [CDH – I like the foreshadowing of what is to come ] “Death by ash, or by ice?” Elías Adriann asked, standing over the convict on a granite stage. [CDH – having read the rest, intro him as Magnate Elias Adriann. I’d like a flushed out setting here with a Deep Point of View (POV) so I get a feel for what emotions your important characters are feeling & the physical responses they have to those emotions. For example, if the convict somehow escapes and will become a main char, give me a description of him and a Deep POV. Is he a large man, is he cowering on the cold stage, is his chin raised and shoulders squared in defiance, etc. SHOW me how he feels. ] It was impossible to find a resemblance between Elías Adriann and the cowering prisoner; without knowledge of the scandal, no one would have guessed they were cousins. [CDH – you show him cowering here, but you need his physical reactions to the situation when you introduce him. If it’s his brother or cousin, maybe Elias leans down and growls ‘brother’ or ‘cousin’ menacingly at the prisoner. Some spat of words to show if Elias is disappointed/angry, or gentle words to show he is remorseful for what is transpiring. This is a great opportunity to SHOW the reader how these 2 feel about each other in this moment. ] Brian Adriann—the magnate’s own blood, now tasked with deciding the means of his execution—only shivered in response. [CDH – this is a bit confusing. It’s good information but its jammed together and didn’t help me understand. I don’t know who the magnate is, or why this blood connection would be important – if it matters, flush it out before you get here so the reader knows its importance. You could consider revising to be something like: Brian Adriann, now expected to decide the means of his own execution, responded with a sob/whine and a shiver. ] Flakes of ice crusted his beard, and hypothermia had left his extremities black and gnarled like overcooked meat. A starry sky illuminated pockets of prison cells at the top of the chasm, where Brian had roomed for the past week. [CDH – I do feel the data is important, but the way it’s presented could flow smoother. Maybe his eyes cast upward for the briefest of seconds to find the window belonging to the room that had imprisoned him for the past week. A starry sky illuminated pockets of prison cells at the top of the chasm. His lip trembled, and he hung his head. Or...maybe he chances a look up at Elias and a tear trails down his face. Then, Elias could react. The link of hypothermia to cooked meat didn’t resonate well – the image didn’t form properly in my mind. Maybe a desc something like: his blackened limbs, shriveled and useless, resembled a deer’s carcass discarded in the snow all winter. I’m trying to give examples of a way you could break out important data that’s been crammed too close together. Sometimes, that gets clunky and your wonderful story won’t evoke the emotions and images you’ve meant your reader to experience. ] Augustins called it The Lid. Weeks of malnutrition up there, so close to the sink hole’s lip, had turned him into a memory of his old self. [CDH – Again, if the prisoner becomes pertinent to the story at a later time by being alive and active in the book’s journey – then it’s important for the reader to know a lot of information about him. If he’s just going to die, you can give a Deep POV from one of his living relatives or friends now or later so the reader feels the impact of his death and how it affected others. ] “Death by ash, or death by ice?” Magnate Elías repeated. He twisted the ring on his forefinger, expression grim, as if taking no pleasure in the trial. Brian whimpered. [CDH – Don’t tell the reader what you assume the char to feel (taking no pleasure in it) – stick to giving physical responses to the scenario to show his emotions. Like: Elias’ skin paled/greyed, an unpleasant/dire expression crossed his face, and he fidgeted with the ring on his forefinger. == SHOW how he’s feeling. I suggest entering to a new line to go from 1 char to another. So, Elias gets his own sentence/paragraph, and when a new character (Brian) or stimulus is presented, it gets their own sentence/paragraph. Keeping the readers separate helps the reader keep track of who is saying and doing what. ] Every sound that escaped his throat summoned vivid images of how I would kill him. Would he care if I had no choice in the matter? Of course not. Mole rats didn’t care who held the knife during their slaughter. But what about the people crowding the street, intently watching the trial? Would they be capable of sympathy? [CDH – Every sound that escaped who’s throat? Maybe say every sound that escaped Brian summoned gruesome/unwarranted images of how I’d have to kill him. I’m guessing how Elias feels because I don’t have a good grip on if he wants to do it or is very reluctant at this point. Maybe ask ‘will he forgive me for having no choice in the manner’ – this would show Elias is holding on to some hope he will be forgiven. Then he could grunt or sneer and think ‘of course not…rats didn’t care who killed them or why, all they know is the blade slicing their throat. If Elias is hoping the crowd will be kinder, more compassionate to his plight as his family’s executioner, I’d say this is a great place to describe that. Maybe he scans the people looking for understanding eyes or body language. Then have him react to whatever he finds in their faces – maybe he scoffs if they don’t seem understanding, or he gives a tiny nod to someone who offers him an understanding smile. ]
The very first line is awesome, and it tells me right off the bat that the character is aware of what he's about to do, like he knows its wrong. But after reading your query, I understand that he has to.
Call Elias "Magnate Elias" from the start. It might cut down on a couple unnecessary words. I think you can cut "Without knowledge of the scandal". The rest of the sentence stands stronger alone imo.
I would say you can cut "the magnate's own blood, now tasked with..." What if you gave him more of a face? Would he submit to whichever fate by hanging his head or maybe challenging Elias with a glare or something? I like the description that follows.
I couldn't really see anything else I wanted to mention. I love your first page!
While I like the information in the paragraphs that follow, it takes me until the very end to really feel grounded in the scene. When I read it again, everything made more sense. Maybe there is a way to establish the scene in a paragraph before the magnate starts talking.
This is just a suggestion, but what if you rearranged things to something like this:
Tonight was the night I would put an innocent man to death.
Would he care if I had no choice in the matter? Of course not. Mole rats didn’t care who held the knife during their slaughter. But what about the people crowding the street, intently watching the trial? Would they be capable of sympathy?
Shame left an acidic taste on my tongue. I didn’t want my part in this trial to affect how they saw me, even when an innocent man was about to die. I think this last sentence needs to be fleshed out more, I’m not sure what you are trying to convey.
“Death by ash, or by ice?” Magnate Elías Adriann asked as he stood over the convict on a granite stage. It was impossible to find a resemblance between Elías and the kneeling prisoner; without knowledge of the scandal, no one would have guessed they were cousins.
Brian Adriann, now tasked with deciding how he wanted to die, only shivered in response. Ice crusted his beard and hypothermia had left his extremities black and gnarled like overcooked meat. A starry sky illuminated pockets of prison cells at the top of the chasm, where Brian had roomed for the past week. Augustins called it The Lid. Weeks of malnutrition up there, so close to the sink hole’s lip, had already turned him into half a memory.
“Death by ash, or death by ice?” Magnate Elías repeated. He twisted the ring on his forefinger, expression grim, as if taking no pleasure in the trial. But I knew the truth.
I hope this helps. I think it sounds very interesting and it definitely makes me want to read more!