Post by Heidi Kneale (Her Grace) on May 15, 2017 21:56:25 GMT -5
ETA: a redraft is further in the comments.
_________________________________________________ When Adrastea, a simple country doctor, receives a marriage proposal from an unlikely suitor, the Dark God Mor-Lath, of course she turns him down!
She's a devotee of a rival god and was raised on chilling tales of this chthonic being who drags the souls of the unrepentant to Dom-al-gol--not the sort of future she had in mind for herself.
Why her? Adrastea's content with the life she has. She likes brewing medicines and saving lives. Mor-Lath is an unnecessary complication in an otherwise pleasant existence.
No way would she ever accept such a proposal.
Not that the Dark God would give up so easily. While he makes it clear he'll only have her willingly, he's making it harder and harder for her to refuse his suit. She wonders, what is he really after?
Adrastea faces a quandary: if she accepts the Dark God's marriage proposal, she'll lose her very soul. But if she rejects his proposal, she could lose so much more.
Either way, the price might be too high.
OF THE DARK is a 125,000-word Fantasy novel, based on the Greek Adrasteia myths. It is the first novel of a completed trilogy.
-------------- I confess I can't seem to make this query work. I've gone over it so many times, I think I've become immune to what works and what doesn't. It's definitely Fantasy, but I don't know if I can describe it as a Romance. A few of the necessary tropes (like an HEA) are missing, but the story is all about their tumultuous courtship. Dark Romance, maybe?
Last Edit: May 17, 2017 1:31:56 GMT -5 by Heidi Kneale (Her Grace): Noted that a redraft is further down in the credits.
Too many paragraphs - it doesn't flow. I'd combine a few of these I think. I'm not sure I get a good sense of her personality either - I'd like a hint of why the Dark God is after her. If you can without giving the whole thing away, that is.
Maybe this (rough, but you get the idea): Adrastea's content with the life she has. She likes brewing medicines and saving lives. Then the Dark God Mor-Lath proposes marriage. Why her? She's a devotee of a rival god and was raised on chilling tales of this chthonic being who drags the souls of the unrepentant to Dom-al-gol--not the sort of future she had in mind for herself.
No way would she ever accept such a proposal.
I really like the last two paragraphs - those show the stakes really well.
Hi! Sounds very cool. I agree that you have too many paragraphs. I really like your opening line, but would lose the ! and change it to something like "it's a very obvious no." And then I would shorten up the backstory a bit and use it more like descriptions: Never mind that she's devoted to his rival, she's heard the tales of.... Then: But when he make it clear that... And finish with the stakes like you do now: Now Adrastea must chose: marry him and lose her soul or refuse and (instead of saying so much more) get specific. You have all the right pieces, in my opinion, sometimes we just have to shake up the snow globe and let the glitter fall into place. Good Luck!
Post by downnineupten on May 16, 2017 8:40:03 GMT -5
Hi Heidi,
I agree with what the others wrote, specifically that there are too many paragraphs, that you need to be more specific about the she could lose so much more (Especially since losing your soul is, I guess traditionally, losing it all, isn't it?), and that the story, nevertheless, sounds intriguing.
Have you experimented with fitting your story to one of the classic query formats, such as hook, character, conflict and consequence? You have it, to some extent, but maybe not boiled down. What do I mean by that? For example, I think the first part of your hook works, the marriage proposal and the who, but I wonder if there is more hook possible than the refusal, especially since she seems to consider later. (I guess because she has to?)
I am wondering, by the way, what he does specifically, to make her even consider it. That might be one angle to take. Are there lots of passages where he comes around and attempts to charm or intimidate her. I sense it's the latter but am not completely sure from the tone. That would be scary, I presume, but I can't tell if that's how we're supposed to view it.
I'm most intrigued by her suspicions that he might be after something else and if she does any investigating or anything of that sort. Maybe that's where your consequences truly are...
... but I don't know. Only you do. I do feel you've got some ironing out to do. I hope my thoughts help.
Last Edit: May 17, 2017 6:57:06 GMT -5 by downnineupten
Hi Heidi! I agree with the others about too many paragraphs. And I really like the ending, sets up the stakes nicely. Though it does leave me with a few questions and maybe you can get more specific here. (A few comments and sugggestions in Red below). Cheers!
When Adrastea, a simple country doctor, receives a marriage proposal from an unlikely suitor, the Dark God Mor-Lath, as a devotee of a rival god, of course she turns him down!
She's a devotee of a rival god and was raised on chilling tales of this chthonic being who drags the souls of the unrepentant to Dom-al-gol--not the sort of future she had in mind for herself. Why her? Adrastea's content with the life she has. She likes brewing medicines and saving lives. Why is he focused on her?Mor-Lath is an unnecessary complication in an othe rwise pleasant existence.Why is he focused on her?
No way would she ever accept such a proposal. IMHO this isn't needed. You've already stated she turned him down and provided information as to why.
Not that the Dark God would give up so easily. While he makes it clear he'll only have her willingly, he's making it harder and harder for her to refuse his suit. [persuit?] Also, how is he making it harder? Is he charming her with his personality? Seducing her with powers? She wonders, what is he really after? Again, IMHO this isn't necessary, it's a repeat from earlier.
Adrastea faces a quandary: if she accepts the Dark God's marriage proposal, she'll lose her very soul. But if she rejects his proposal, she could lose so much more. [What more could she lose? Try and be specific here.]
Either way, the price might be too high. [Might be? Or is?]
OF THE DARK is a 125,000-word Fantasy novel, based on the Greek Adrasteia myths. It is the first novel of a completed trilogy.
-------------- I confess I can't seem to make this query work. I've gone over it so many times, I think I've become immune to what works and what doesn't. It's definitely Fantasy, but I don't know if I can describe it as a Romance. A few of the necessary tropes (like an HEA) are missing, but the story is all about their tumultuous courtship. Dark Romance, maybe?
Post by jessicalewis on May 16, 2017 14:36:47 GMT -5
Hi Heidi,
I don't have much to add, but this seems more like a bunch of ideas than a query. I'd go back to the basics with this one:
1st P- introduce MC, sprinkle in voice, tell a bit about world 2nd P- inciting incident 3rd P- stakes, what will happen if she fails, hint of what's to come
General advice: don't use exclamation points and don't mention that the trilogy is completed. If an agent picks this up you'll have to do edits anyway, which more than likely means you'll have to tweak/overhaul your other two. Just say something like "it's the first in a planned series" or even better "it is a standalone with series potential."
Sorry I couldn't be more helpful! I wish you luck!!
Post by Heidi Kneale (Her Grace) on May 17, 2017 1:30:46 GMT -5
Okay, I've redrafted, taking everyone's opinions into account. I've shortened it from too many paragraphs, eliminated (I hope) some of the vagueness without giving away spoilers.
Does this work better?
_____________________
Adrastea Healer loves her simple country life of brewing medicines and saving lives. Then the Dark God Mor-Lath proposes marriage. As a devotee of a rival god, she was raised on chilling tales of this chthonic being who drags the souls of the unrepentant to Dom-al-gol. His choice of her as a bride doesn't make sense.
Undaunted by her refusal, Mor-Lath insists on courting her. Sometimes he is charming, but other times, she sees him for the dark god he truly is. Adrastea wonders, what is he really after?
Adrastea faces a quandary: if she accepts the Dark God's marriage proposal, she'll lose her very soul. But if she rejects his proposal, the whole world might be at stake. Either way, the price is too high.
OF THE DARK is a 125,000-word Fantasy novel, based on the Greek Adrasteia myths.
I liked your original first sentence much more than the new one. The original made me laugh out loud and instantly hooked me. I wanted to know more about the dark god and the girl he was romancing. Also, it had a strong voice ("of course she turns him down") which gave me a feeling for the character. Comparatively, the new opening is generic and doesn't get to the interesting part until the next sentence.
What I did like about the new version: you make it more clear what the stakes are: "the whole world". You also indicate that why he's courting her will be part of the plot's mystery. The ending line is better, too.
Post by downnineupten on May 17, 2017 7:14:17 GMT -5
Hi again,
I agree with katydid that the original first sentence is stronger. Actually, I like missy's rewrite with the phrase "as a devotee of a rival god" because it makes the rejection work for me as part of the hook.
You don't have much time but I think you're on the right track. I think you lost voice throughout in general and need get that wah back in. Maybe with a few telling details that show his charm and his dark god bad-ness. For example, does he shower her with any gifts. (Lovers of goth accessories might be very tempted to marry a Dark God…? The boots, the skull rings...)
The stakes are still not turning my knuckles white. Maybe whole world is too abstract for me. Is there something in the loss of her world, some piece of it, maybe even her customers or her apprentice or something, that could make those stakes more personal and human-centered? Maybe that's what it needs. Something like that?
Again though, your story sounds compelling. I guess you just want to tighten this up so the agent will not doubt your writing chops, because I think the story idea itself should hook 'em.
Last Edit: May 17, 2017 7:16:26 GMT -5 by downnineupten
I liked Missy's re-write of your first sentence. Just use healer instead of doctor, and it will show voice & fantasy. I do agree the "whole world" is maybe too big - a specific example might be helpful. Good luck!
Post by Heidi Kneale (Her Grace) on May 18, 2017 1:14:02 GMT -5
Wanted to thank you all for your insight and opinions on what worked and what didn't. I've been struggling for at least a year with this query and could never seem to get it right. Eventually one's brain numbs up to what is overfamiliar. With your help I was able to look at it anew and I believe I've ended up with a better query.